Consumer bills to jump as networks score court victory over regulator

Consumer bills to jump as networks score court victory over regulator

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Australian Energy Regulator loses costly Federal Court battle to control how much NSW network operators can charge for power.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Australian consumers already suffering from some of the highest electricity prices in the developed world are facing even higher bills after a group of NSW network operators won a Federal Court challenge against the national energy regulator over the amount they can charge for power.

In a bitter battle that started more than two years ago with the Australian Competition Tribunal, three NSW electricity distribution firms – Ausgrid, Endeavour Energy and Essential Energy – sought to overturn price cuts of about 20 per cent imposed by the Australian Energy Regulator in its April 30 pricing determination.


The unprecedented step would see the networks – including the NSW government owned assets, Ausgrid and Endeavour – spend millions on legal fees fighting the AER’s efforts to rein in their costs.

The AER – which was, rather ironically, also facing a legal challenge from the Public Interest Advocacy Centre, which had argued the AER’s suggested revenue cuts weren’t deep enough – has previously come under fire for allowing too much spending by the networks.

Indeed, as we reported at the time, the AER’s April 30 decision was more lenient than its initial determination of November 2014, when it fairly slapped down the NSW grid operators’ bid to boost spending by as much as 50 per cent.

Now, the regulator’s efforts to rein in spending by the networks, and by association any further rises in electricity prices, have not been supported by the Federal Court.

In particular, the AER has lost the battle over how much the networks could spend on operating costs and the cost of debt.

The decision is likely to have huge consequences for consumer in NSW and across the country, even though the government is considering changing the rules on the networks’ avenue of appeal in the future.

“This decision is disappointing for NSW and ACT electricity and gas customers overall,” said AER chair Paula Conboy in a statement on Wednesday, noting that the decision might also have implications for customers in other states.

“Our 2015 decisions set lower revenues than proposed by the network businesses in NSW and ACT, partly because we concluded that costs above efficient levels should be funded by the network owners, not customers,” she said.

Conboy said the AER would now carefully consider the judgement, as well as the next steps and any implications for these and other network revenue determinations.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

  1. juxx0r 4 years ago

    Is that another onestepoffthegrid for all of us?

    • john 4 years ago

      Quiet possibly until you are charged for the supply charge because it passes your lot.

      • Dixiemespinosa 4 years ago

        If you were looking for a way to earn some extra income every week… Look no more!!!! Here is a great opportunity for everyone to make $95/per hour by working in your free time on your computer from home… I’ve been doing this for 6 months now and last month i’ve earned my first five-figure paycheck ever!!!! Learn more about it on following link

  2. David McKay 4 years ago

    Another example of the benefits (not) of de-regulation for the consumer!!!

  3. Chris Fraser 4 years ago

    I trust the networks are not concerned at all by the threat to grid usage.
    They behave like skydivers in mid-jump, taking out knives and cutting the strings to their parachutes.
    I think this Network beating up on AER is not going to last. Eventually, all small generators are going to be contributors to the grid – eventually they are going to have to discuss their proposals with more numerous small generators.
    The gold plating has not stopped and that’s disappointing.

  4. Robin_Harrison 4 years ago

    A last-ditch feeding frenzy, like an incandescent light globe just before it blows.

    • BushAxe 4 years ago

      It’s got that feeling of maximising returns while they still can.

  5. Farmer Dave 4 years ago

    This could be a spectacular own goal for the networks! It is also yet another example of the short-term thinking that is endemic in Australian business.

  6. Joe 4 years ago

    With the NSW Government having privatised the Distributors on the basis that consumers will win through lower prices and more efficient services, I’m going to love hearing Premier Gladys “complain” when the new retail electricity prices hit the fan from 1st July. Can’t have it both ways.

  7. Gnällgubben 4 years ago

    The grid connection is a natural monopoly so it’s not suited for free market operation. No one has more than one grid connection to the house so everyone is stuck with whatever operator happen to own that area which is free to set whatever price (unless regulated). This is bad for everybody, the distribution grid should be publicly owned instead and offered to every participant, generator or consumer, at a fair and non-discriminatory rate.

Comments are closed.

Get up to 3 quotes from pre-vetted solar (and battery) installers.